Own a private island in the U.S. — if you’re willing to spend one night there

By Brandon Lee

Own a private island in the U.S.

Imagine owning your very own slice of the Atlantic — waves lapping at the shore, seals basking on the rocks, and nothing but starlight above. But before you sign on the dotted line, there’s just one condition: you have to spend a night there, alone.

A rugged paradise just off the Maine coast

Tucked away in the waters of Maine lies Duck Ledges Island, a rustic, 1.5-acre haven that feels worlds apart despite being just a 10-minute boat ride from the mainland. With no trees to block the view, the island offers an unbroken panorama of the ocean — a summer dream for nature lovers and solitude seekers alike.

It’s not just the views that make this place extraordinary. The island is home to a vibrant ecosystem: lobsters crawl along the shores, eagles soar overhead, and seals raise their pups on the sun-warmed rocks. You’re not just buying property here; you’re stepping into a living, breathing wildlife sanctuary.

No streetlights, no neighbours — just stars

Billy Milliken, the island’s current owner and a seasoned real estate agent, has held onto this gem since 2007. When he bought it, the only building was a crumbling structure — now replaced by a carefully rebuilt off-grid cabin that sleeps four and boasts sweeping views of the Atlantic.

But Billy isn’t looking for just any buyer. He wants someone who truly understands what it means to live with nature, not just on it. His one firm condition? You must spend a night alone on the island before he’ll consider your offer.

“There’s no light pollution out there,” Billy explains. “The night sky is pitch black — the kind that makes you feel small in the best possible way.”

Beauty, yes — but also brutal winters

The island’s charm is undeniable in the warmer months. But Billy is upfront about the harsh reality of Maine’s off-season. From late autumn to early spring, the island is lashed by icy winds, snow, and bone-chilling storms. There’s no running water, no heating system — just you, the sea, and whatever nature decides to throw your way.

That’s exactly why he insists on the overnight test. “I’m sticking to my plan,” he says. “To be considered a buyer, you need to experience it.”

This is not a decision for the faint-hearted or the simply curious. It’s a lifestyle shift — the kind that demands respect for nature and the resilience to live in sync with it.

Not for hunters or developers

Billy has already turned down offers from buyers whose intentions didn’t align with his values — including one who wanted to use the island for hunting. For him, this isn’t just a transaction; it’s a matter of stewardship.

He’s seeking someone who will cherish the island as he has — someone willing to protect the wildlife and preserve the fragile ecosystem that makes Duck Ledges so unique.

So, if you’re imagining a quick flip or a party spot, this probably isn’t for you. But if you’re drawn to the idea of watching seals play at sunset or falling asleep to the sound of waves, it might just be the adventure of a lifetime.

At $339,000, it’s not exactly cheap — but then again, how often do you get the chance to own a private island, let alone one with such a storybook setting?

Just be ready to spend a night with the stars, the seals, and your own thoughts before you call it home.

Similar Posts

2.9/5 - (10 votes)

4 thoughts on “Own a private island in the U.S. — if you’re willing to spend one night there”

  1. wow, If I only had more than $3,000 in my account I would be ecstatic to live there I thought it was like just one night and you could have your own private area away from humans and actually helping to protect animals and this is what life is about I mean I don’t think I would leave if I could live there I guess I have to find work or I could fish but water would be a problem so all I know is it looks like a dream come true whoever owns this is the luckiest person on the planet no amount of money could account for what he has I mean you could ask for a billion dollars and it still wouldn’t even make sense to me because it’s just such a beautiful spot I would give anything to have it and to guard it and to just look up at the sky at night and hear the waves crashing and watch all the beautiful creatures just living their life on this rock in space. obviously we’re all going to die one day and if this is where I could live and hang out till that that day happens I’d be a happy man. whoever owns this is a very lucky person.

    Reply
    • Let’s pool our money and buy the island. The equity share will be calculated pro rata based on each investor’s contribution.
      What do you think?

      Reply

Leave a Comment

Share to...