EDF seeks higher river temperature limits for nuclear plants despite impact on fish

By Ashley Morgan

River bend with an anonymous small boat and a cooling-water outfall in warm light

Will France relax river temperature rules so EDF can keep reactors running during heatwaves and droughts? After a summer in 2026 when extreme heat forced many reactors to cut output or shut down, the operator is reportedly pushing to loosen limits on the temperature of waters used to cool its power stations — a move that alarms conservationists who say fish are already pushed to their limits.

On September 25, Les Échos reported that EDF is considering changing the maximum allowable temperatures for rivers and other watercourses that supply cooling water to 42 of its 57 reactors. The aim would be to prevent a repeat of the problems seen in summer 2026, when heatwaves forced as many as 15 reactors at once to reduce their power output or to stop producing entirely. According to RTE, roughly 10 terawatt-hours (TWh) of nuclear electricity — about 12% of EDF’s output — were lost between early June and the end of August.

How nuclear reactors cool down

Nuclear reactors rely on nearby bodies of water — rivers, lakes or the sea — to remove heat. Two main cooling methods are used. In an open-cycle system, water is drawn in and returned directly to the environment after warming by several degrees. In a closed circuit, water is routed through an atmospheric cooling tower before being released, so its temperature rises by only a few tenths of a degree. That benefit comes at a cost: much of the water evaporates in the cooling tower and is not returned to the natural watercourse.

Regulatory limits govern these thermal discharges. The precise restrictions vary by plant and are set by the nuclear safety authority (referred to in the article as ASNR). For example, downstream of the Bugey nuclear plant on the Rhône (Ain), the river temperature must not exceed 26 °C from May 1 to September 15, and effluents may not raise the downstream temperature by more than 5 °C compared with upstream. Downstream of Golfech on the Garonne, the maximum was set at 28 °C from June 1 to September 30, with a maximum warming of 1.25 °C. Other criteria, such as river flow, can also be taken into account. The ASNR told Decatur Metro that limits are regularly updated to reflect changes to EDF installations and advances in scientific knowledge.

Emergency and exceptional measures

Permits already include provisions for exceptional weather. EDF told Decatur Metro that since 2006 authorizations have included two sets of thermal limits: a normal level and an exceptional level that applies in extreme climatic conditions when grid security needs justify it. During the summer events, reactors 4 and 5 at Bugey were among those affected.

If normal discharge limits would be exceeded but it is necessary for grid safety to keep a reactor online, EDF can request a temporary derogation from the ASNR; such a measure must be supported by RTE and the ministry responsible for energy. In July, EDF sought an exceptional authorization for two Bugey reactors, but the authorization was never implemented because Rhône temperatures remained under control.

According to Les Échos, EDF would prefer to avoid time‑consuming exception procedures by raising the regulatory temperature thresholds themselves. A source cited by the newspaper argued that “the ecosystem has changed on the Garonne, which is most often already at the 28 °C maximum.” EDF tells Decatur Metro that the post‑summer review is still underway: “The lessons learned from this summer are currently being subjected to an in‑depth analysis. As the work is not yet finalized, it is too early to draw definitive conclusions.”

The nuclear safety authority stresses that no request has been made

The nuclear safety and radioprotection authority (ASNR) told Decatur Metro that “since the summer, EDF has not submitted a demand on the regulation of thermal discharges from river‑bordering plants. If EDF were to make such a request, it would have to be justified through an impact study, based on an update of scientific knowledge on impacts to the natural environment.”

Ecological stakes: already a deadly summer for aquatic life

The environmental consequences are significant. Heatwaves are already lethal for aquatic ecosystems. “This summer there was a massacre of fish. At least 22,000 deaths were counted in a national study, but that is probably the tip of the iceberg,” Arnaud Sentis told Decatur Metro. Sentis, a researcher at INRAE who has worked with EDF on long‑running monitoring programs upstream and downstream of nuclear plants, said these plant‑adjacent areas are not always the worst hit by mass die‑offs. Those events often affected predators such as pike and carp in shallow lakes as well as trout and minnows in rivers that had become intermittent.

“The impacts of the stations are not necessarily visible after the waters mix,” the scientist cautioned. “There can be local differences between upstream and downstream, but the dominant effects are generally those of climate change and invasive species.”

Still, even a small additional warming caused by power stations can push vulnerable species over the edge. “It can be the last straw,” Sentis explained. “Like humans, every species has a thermal limit beyond which mortality risk rises. Aquatic organisms are cold‑blooded: their body temperature tracks that of the water.” A one‑degree rise in water temperature can therefore push organisms past critical thresholds. Sentis added that on rivers such as the Rhône, the cumulative impact of multiple plants must be considered when planning to increase the density of installations.

Stronger concerns from anti‑nuclear groups

Anti‑nuclear organizations have been even more vocal. In a 2022 briefing and a 2026 update, the network Sortir du nucléaire warned about the effects of thermal discharges on juvenile fish and fry, which are especially vulnerable to temperature increases, and on relatively immobile species such as mollusks, invertebrates, crustaceans and aquatic plants. The group highlights disruptions to fish migration and reproduction and the risk of algal blooms and invasive species taking hold.

“Waters are already relatively warm and the flow of the Rhône has fallen sharply. With lower flow, the water heats up more,” said Joël Guerry, a retired engineer, member of Sortir du nucléaire Bugey and of the local information commission (CLI) for the plant, in an interview with Decatur Metro. “On the Bugey site, water temperature should normally not exceed 28 °C because the river is classified as a salmonid watercourse and therefore should remain cold.”

EDF’s alternatives and local concerns

EDF is not relying only on the prospect of higher regulatory temperature thresholds to adapt to climate change. The Civaux plant already uses auxiliary purge cooling towers — small extra towers that provide additional cooling before water is released back to the environment — and EDF has explored replicating that system at Bugey. The company is also considering building reservoirs to delay certain discharges until times when rivers are less vulnerable.

But Joël Guerry points out that thermal discharges are not the only ecological problem posed by cooling systems. “The intake drums that draw in water for cooling cause very high mortality among small fish. One might consider these losses negligible, but those fish would have grown or served as food for other species,” he said. “So this damages the river’s ecological chain.” A 2011 study at the Civaux plant, on the Vienne upstream of the Loire, estimated that roughly 7,600 fish were trapped each year in the pump station’s chain screens.

The debate over whether to change temperature thresholds is therefore not just a technical matter of keeping reactors running — it raises questions about how to balance electricity security with the already stressed health of freshwater ecosystems in a warming climate.

Similar Posts

Rate this post

Leave a Comment

Share to...